Thursday, June 21, 2012

This Is Where I Leave You: The Movie!

Details continue to emerge about a possible film adaptation for Jonathan Tropper’s fantastic 2009 novelThis Is Where I Leave You. When I caught Tropper at a reading in July 2010, he’d finished the screenplay and mentioned that a “famous director” was attached, but he still seemed skeptical that the movie would ever see the light of day. “Any movie that doesn’t have a superhero doesn’t get made anymore,” he said. Now, though, it seems like a realistic possibility. Let’s take a look at what we know about the film so far, and gauge its chances.
Source Material
With lines like “He is the Paul McCartney of our family: better looking than the rest of us, always facing a different direction in pictures, and occasionally rumored to be dead” and “My marriage ended the way these things do: with paramedics and cheesecake,” the source material is as film-ready as it comes. Again, Tropper wrote the screenplay, so confidence is high that the source material will turn out well on screen. At that July 2010 reading, Tropper mentioned that one of his favorite writers is Richard Russo, who had great success adapting his own novel Empire Falls into a terrific HBO miniseries. Oh, and the story about siblings coming to sit shiva for their father in the midst of their own relationship and personal crises is as rich with built-in conflict and comedy as source material for a film gets. Here's my long-ago review of This Is Where I Leave You, if you're interested. 
I don’t know whether Adam Shankman is the “famous director” Tropper said was attached two years ago, but this guy’s not exactly a household name. Most recently, he’s directed the Tom Cruise vehicle Rock of Ages. Many of the reviews of Rock of Ages have not been good, so far — which may not be all Shankman's fault, but still. So, that’s not a good omen for this movie. As well, probably Shankman’s two most well-known directing credits are 2007′s Hairspray (which I haven’t seen) and  2001′s Jennifer Lopez/Matt McConaughey dud The Wedding Planner (which I’m REALLY GLAD I haven’t seen). So, frankly, confidence isn’t high on this one, but you never know…
All the actors, including Jason Bateman, Jason Sudeikis, Zac Efron, Leslie Mann, Goldie Hawn, and Malin Akerman, are in “various stages of negotiations,” according to most of the Hollywood trade pubs. If they all wind up in the film, this is a very, very solid cast. Presumably, Bateman plays Judd (rumors still swirl about exact roles), the protagonist and narrator. Bateman’s constant comic exasperation, as displayed in Horrible Bosses and Arrested Development, will make him a fantastic Judd. A+ casting here. 
Additional note: When I saw Tropper at BEA in New York, I asked him what he thought of Bateman as Judd. He paused a beat and then said he was thrilled. He said he'd sent Bateman scripts for all his other novels, but This Is Where I Leave You is the first time Bateman said 'yes.' I told him I thought it was a fantastic choice, too. 
Rumors are that Sudeikis would play Judd’s radio disc jockey boss whom Judd catches sleeping with his wife (not sure about this — Sudeikis could do the cheesy DJ way, way over the top here), Efron would play youngest brother and playboy Phillip (I’ll abstain here. I hate Efron, but this might work.), Mann would play oldest sister Wendy (Mann can be a good harpy, so good here), Akerman would play Judd’s cheating wife (she’s hot, so okay, but I have no idea) and Hawn would play the recently-turned-lesbian mother (inspired casting here!). It’ll come down to chemistry, since so much of the comedy lies in the family’s squabbles, but on a role-by-role basis, I think this has an above-average chance of working.
Wild Card
No rumors yet on who will play Paul, Judd’s older ex-jock brother — it’s a critical role for the “brother-bonding” scenes. And I’m not sure about Shankman — he’s never really handled an ensemble cast before, and hasn’t really directed anything that’s done well. But with great source material, Tropper adapting his own novel, and Bateman as Judd, confidence is good to great on this film. What do you think?

CONFIDENCE INDEX: 6.5 (out of 10) 

Note: This post, minus a few updates, originally appeared on Book Riot.


  1. Oh that's so weird.. I think of Adam Shankman as a choreographer who makes dance movies, LOL... not sure how that will translate to this one.

    1. Yeah, I guess he does have quite a few choreographer credits, too. I don't like this - it's not a freakin' musical! :)

  2. While I haven't yet read the book (it's on my TBR list) the mention of Shankman potentially having anything to do with this fills me with dread. While I have actually had the misfortune of sitting through The Wedding Planner, I think his real low point came when he produced the Oscars telecast in 2010. He eliminated the Best Song performances in favor of endless montages and some weird interpretative dance number. It was horrendous.

    1. Oh, that was Shankman, too?! (The Oscars.) Oh NOOOOO! This is not good news. Not good news at all.

  3. So, I hated this book, but I think the Goldie Hawn casting in spot-on, and rather obvious -- she's the first person I thought of when I read the book, which always seemed like a movie in waiting to me. I have proof in my Goodreads review, written about two years ago!

    I can see this making a decent movie.

    1. Whaaaa...?! You hated the book? No accounting for taste, I suppose. ;)

  4. Jason Bateman? Yes. Perfect.

  5. Jason Bateman is a REALLY good choice... I always imagined Paul Rudd as Judd though. I don't know why, he just popped up in my head while I was reading it because most of the characters he plays are like Judd a little bit. Paul Rudd should definitely be in the movie though playing someone... it just seems like the type of story he'd be in.